Print the page
Increase font size

Posted January 18, 2023

Sean Ring

By Sean Ring

Right on Cue, the Empire Index Collapses

Happy Hump Day from an overcast Northern Italy!

It’s still chilly here in Europe, and I’ve got the sweater on while imbibing my cup of joe.

As soon as I hit “submit” for yesterday’s piece about the sky not falling, I realized I had failed to mention something important.

It was an admission: I was, and am, Chicken Little.

As I was writing, I realized that I was the person I was trying to convince that everything was fine.

But it’s not. Not really.

In one Rude, I wrote economist Yuri Maltsev’s excellent quote, “A pessimist is an optimist with better information.”

I want to be an optimist. I really, really do. It’s my natural disposition.

But the macro numbers are coming thick and fast… and man, they’re uglier than the pictures on Hunter’s laptop.

The latest of them is this month’s Empire Manufacturing Index.

If it were a little down, I wouldn’t have cared much.

But it plunged, like an airplane heading into the ground perpendicularly.

Which usually means the Philly Fed will be a disaster as well. We’ll find out tomorrow morning.

But first, let’s see what happened in New York State.

A Brief Review of the Empire State Manufacturing Index

First, what is it?

It’s a monthly survey of manufacturers in New York state. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York conducts the survey. The bank sends the survey monthly to business leaders representing a wide swath of the manufacturing sector.

The headline number summarizes general business conditions in New York state. The index is widely watched for insights into the state and direction of manufacturing in New York state.

The index measures the health of New York manufacturers relative to a year ago and has been strongly correlated with industrial production nationally since it began in 1982.

It’s essential but not as widely trusted as the Philly Fed because the Philly Fed covers more manufacturing in the US.

Second, let’s see how it’s calculated:

The general business conditions index and the indexes for the other 11 indicators are calculated by adding the percentage of "increase" responses and then subtracting the percentage of "decrease" responses.

If 30% of survey respondents marked "increase," 50% chose "no change," and 20% picked "decrease," then the index would show a reading of 10. Index readings are released as absolute numbers to one place after the decimal point.

With that said, let’s see what happened in the January survey.

The Empire State Manufacturing Index Falls Off a Cliff in January

Business activity shrunk in New York State, according to firms responding to the January 2023 Empire State Manufacturing Survey.

  • The headline general business conditions index fell twenty-two points to -32.9.
  • New orders and shipments declined substantially.
  • Delivery times held steady, and inventories edged higher.
  • Employment growth stalled, and the average workweek was shortened.
  • Input price increases slowed considerably, and selling price increases also moderated.
  • Looking ahead, firms expect little improvement in business conditions over the next six months.

The Empire State Manufacturing Index plunged to -32.9 in January, significantly lower than the -7.0 forecast and December's reading of -11.2. The index is at its lowest level since the Great Financial Crisis of 2008, save the 2020 government-mandated private sector shutdown.


Only eleven percent of respondents reported that conditions had improved over the month, and forty-four percent said that conditions had worsened.

After looking at the overall picture, let’s look at new orders since they’ll determine how many employees we’ll need and what that’ll do to pricing.

New Orders Sharply Decline

New orders have been dropping since September. These are the most important leading indicators of future production.

They're a leading indicator of future employment and sales, too. And they're also a valuable gauge of earnings growth, which is why investors and companies closely watch them.


Index for Number of Employees Plunges to Lowest Level in 2 Years

You’d expect employee numbers to fall, as there aren’t any new orders.

The number of employees fell to 2.8 in January, the lowest reading since the government-mandated private sector shutdown in 2020. This was a sharp drop from December's reading of 14.0.


After this, you’d expect prices also to fall since there’s not much demand.

Prices Paid and Received Indices Fall Sharply but Remain Positive

The prices paid index fell sharply, to 33.0 from 50.5 in December; the prices received index also fell sharply but remains positive at 18.8 in January compared with 25.2 in December.


Here is what some point to as a bright spot in the survey.

Since both prices paid and received dropped, this corroborates the theory that inflation is cooling.

But as my good friend Mark Rossano would say, “It’s like going from 150 mph to 153 mph and thinking you’re slowing down.”

He’s absolutely right. Prices are still going up. But they’re going up at a slower rate than they were before.

So, we’re experiencing disinflation rather than deflation.

The truth is we need prices to fall, not merely slow.

One Bit of Good News

Now we know the current Empire index (blue line) is terrible. But the expected index (red line) is positive.


That means six months from now, New York State managers think things will be back in growth mode.

It’s not a certainty but a best guess. And that’s not bad.

In Other Bad News, China…

Those that think China is going to rescue the world economy are misguided.

First, China admitted (finally) that its population has fallen for the first time since 1961.

If demographics is destiny, then this isn’t China’s century.

From the BBChé:

China's population has fallen for the first time in 60 years, with the national birth rate hitting a record low - 6.77 births per 1,000 people.

The population in 2022 - 1.4118 billion - fell by 850,000 from 2021.

China's birth rate has been declining for years, prompting a slew of policies to try to slow the trend.

But seven years after scrapping the one-child policy, it has entered what one official described as an "era of negative population growth."

The birth rate in 2022 was also down from 7.52 in 2021, according to China's National Bureau of Statistics, which released the figures on Tuesday.

The second bit of bad news is that China is experiencing the lowest GDP growth rate in 50 years.

According to the positively gleeful Outlook India, China’s GDP sank to 3% in 2022, its second lowest in 50 Years.

The annual GDP of China totaled 21.02 trillion yuan ($17.94 trillion) in 2022, falling below the 5.5 percent official target, the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) said.

A declining birth rate and a declining GDP? What new Asian devilry is this?

Wrap Up

Between the US economy rolling over and the Chinese not producing anything like kids and output, we’re in a pickle.

Europe won’t rescue us, and I suspect neither will Oceania, Africa, or Latin America.

So buckle up, but keep in mind we may still have a momentum stock market rally here.

Until tomorrow.

These Three Things Keep Your Employees’ Noses to the Grindstone

Posted January 31, 2023

By Sean Ring

Determining which carrots and sticks to drive results is easier than you think.

No-Vax Djokovic Wins Australian Open

Posted January 30, 2023

By Sean Ring

Bill Gates watches as Djokovic dominates the next generation.

FB Reinstates Trump, But Nobody Gives a Zuck

Posted January 27, 2023

By Sean Ring

After a two-year ban, Donald Trump is allowed back on Facebook. Trump has too much riding financially on his TruthSocial to post on FB. FB is frantically trying to get back into...

Things I Like Right Now

Posted January 26, 2023

By Sean Ring

Bears, beware; it looks like the bulls are taking over for a bit.

Sure, Sloppy Joe will brag about gas prices because you’re not looking at diesel prices.

Posted January 25, 2023

By Sean Ring

Sure, Sloppy Joe will brag about gas prices because you’re not looking at diesel prices.

One More Test For the SPX

Posted January 24, 2023

Ok, we’re above the 200-day moving average. Now we’ve got a bigger fish to fry.