Print the page
Increase font size

Posted October 25, 2021

Sean Ring

By Sean Ring

What Exactly Are Carbon Credits?

Good morning!

Hope you survived and thrived on your Monday.

Today, well discuss carbon credits. By the end of this Rude, youll be able to speak intelligently to anyone about the darn things.

Again, Ill be borrowing from our sister site, carboncredits.com.

What are Carbon Credits?

A carbon credit is an allowance for a company holding the credit to emit carbon emissions or greenhouse gases. A single credit equals one ton of carbon dioxide to be emitted or the mass equivalent to carbon dioxide for other gases. Companies hold many credits, as many as they wish to purchase to balance out their emissions.

Why cant companies stockpile carbon credits?

There are two characteristics of carbon credits. Excess credits are sold by companies to recoup finances and the amount of credits a company can hold is capped. These points encourage companies to sell their excess credits to other companies, as excess credits will result in fines.

How does a company create a carbon credit?

Credits are created when a project is deemed to have eliminated 1 ton of greenhouse emissions. Planting a forest that would eliminate 1 ton of carbon emissions would be enough to create a credit. Credits do however decay over time which means companies continually need to create new ideas to remove emissions.

Many companies also specialize in trading and investing in credits. They will buy credits from large companies and resell them to whoever may need those credits. As the price of carbon continually rises, so too does the value of the credits.

What are Carbon Offsets?

Buying a carbon offset or credit is the right thing to do for the planet. Offsets do not simply kick the global warming can down the road: They create a way to buy their way into the problem, not out of it.

Offsets can trade in the compliance markets (like those from the Clean Development Mechanism or Joint Implementation projects). However, the majority are traded in voluntary markets.

Carbon offsets can also have benefits such as job creation, water conservation, flood prevention, and preservation of biodiversity.

Below is a chart that shows the annual credit generation from carbon offset projects in the voluntary carbon market. In 2020, annual credit production in the voluntary carbon market was a record 223 million.

Courtesy of: Katusa Research

How Offsets are Created

A portion of offset spending also goes toward investing in futuristic technology for carbon sequestration and emissions mitigation. Many methods of carbon offset creation, like direct air capture, are in the very incipient stages of development. Increasing demand for those novel offset types enables large-scale deployment, rapidly making them more economical.

Eventually, new technologies will reach a tipping point. For example, Prometheuss forges are expected to remove 11 GT of CO2 from the air each year by 2050.

Thats the equivalent of 20% of current emissions, all from a single company.

And its only possible with heavy, ongoing investment in carbon credits and offsetseven risky ones.

Types of Carbon Offset Projects

Carbon offset projects are grouped into 2 categories:

  1. Avoidance/Reduction projects like renewable energy (wind, solar) and methane capture
  2. Removal/Sequestration Projects like reforestation and direct carbon capture

The physical cost of offsetting incentivizes the companies to identify operational leaksareas where emissions can be reduced or eliminatedthen begins to force the company to eliminate emissions throughout their entire value chain.

Companies that use offsets at least in part to manage their emissions implement emissions reductions at a higher rate, spend almost five times as much on reductions, and mitigate or eliminate a greater proportion of their emissions as those that do not use offsets.

Investing in offsets also helps the earth through the offsets themselves. Reforestation increases biodiversity, and the installation of solar panels and wind turbines pulls energy demand away from coal and fossil fuel supplies.

A carbon offset can be resold multiple times but once retired, it can no longer be resold. To ensure there is no double sale, a carbon offset must be kept on a registry. This registry keeps track of the issuance and retirement of offsets.

Investing Implications

Investing in carbon offsetswhether for better financing terms or to help prevent further climate changeencourages competitors in the marketplace to do the same.

Etsy, the online market for handcrafted goods, purchased high-quality carbon offsets for all of its competitors for a single day and committed to offsetting its own carbon footprint in the future. It calculated the total cost of doing so at just a penny per package, proving that its an expense every other retailer can afford to bear.

Demonstrating the economic feasibility of emissions mitigation encourages other companies to do it, even if its for a reason other than saving the planet.

In fact, it may be a combination of all of these reasons and more: creating a more resilient supply chain, improving supplier relationships, and increasing employee retention are all co-benefits of purchasing carbon credits and carbon offsets, ensuring your company can thrive forever.

Who Verifies Carbon Credits?

The market for carbon offsets is voluntary theres no government agency setting a standard emission reduction that must be met for eligible projects. There are not even established criteria for what makes a viable carbon offset project.

Take a quick scan over the voluntary carbon markets out there and youll see a dizzyingly broad range of projects on offer. Renewable energy projects are always popular, as well as projects that lock carbon emissions away. Youll also find forest management projects. Biogas projects. Water quality projects. The list goes on and on, with some of the projects seeming more and more unrelated to actual greenhouse gas emissions reductions.

A Wild West of Carbon Credits

Technically speaking, carbon credits are government-issued carbon allowances. Under the right conditions, they can be bought and sold in different exchanges. But participation is limited to entities (typically companies) in areas with an Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS). In the US, only California has a state-administered carbon trading program.

That leaves a growing demand for companies to take responsibility for their greenhouse gas emissions, but no formal market to meet that demand.

Thats where the idea of carbon offsets comes in.

Carbon offsets are carbon credits traded on the voluntary market. By investing in carbon reductions projects, companies can offset the carbon they produce.

Offsets dont fall under existing government regulation. Theyre an entirely natural market response to a new demand.

But that does raise an important question: who verifies carbon credits?

Without a government regulator, the market is left to sort out its own verification activities. In a new and growing market, that means a lot of uncertainty, but also an immense opportunity for any entity that can oversee other carbon offset providers.

Market-led verification

Think of third-party verification, and you probably think of some bureaucratic seal of approval. Thats how most regulation works. Government sets standards and administers those standards through agencies that police different sectors of the market.

But verification isnt only about meeting certain regulatory requirements.

Verification ensures that consumers receive proper value for their money.

In the open market, the job of ensuring proper value verification often falls to a third party. That third party often has an outsize influence in the development of the broader market, and the voluntary carbon market is no exception.

Multiple market approaches

Need a carbon offset? Youll have two options when it comes to purchasing them.

You can buy carbon offsets individually, selecting the offsets and the price you pay for them. Sites like Nori and GoldStandard leave much of the verification process to the consumer. Its up to you to examine the projects and select the ones you think will provide the greatest impact.

Voluntary offset market sites like these do some verification on their own, of course. By deeming a particular program worthy of being offered on the site, Nori and GoldStandard are implicitly verifying the programs.

Other offset markets provide offsets in a portfolio. By bundling offsets from different projects together, companies like Native can sell a wide range of offsets in one package. Its a bit of verification through diversification not every project will be as successful as others in actually reducing CO2 emissions. But by purchasing offsets that cover more than one project, investors can be confident that stronger offsets will offset weaker ones.

Building a new verification ecosystem

But what goes into a carbon offset? Who calculates the tonnes of carbon locked away in a given program? Who measures the carbon emissions reductions?

The smart carbon offset provider realizes that the offset market marks a golden opportunity to establish itself as the ultimate verification tool. Any company that can claim to have the best verification process can position itself to lead the rapidly-growing offset market for years to come.

The proof is in the pudding. The company that can prove its carbon offsets contributed to sustainable development benefits will have a notch in its belt. Anyone who can demonstrate clearly-achieved GHG emission reductions will be able to use that success to attract more investors to its projects.

In the voluntary carbon market, better verification leads to demonstrable results. And in a world increasingly aware of environmental damage, demonstrable results will lead to greater sales of carbon offsets.

One example of a company attempting to do just that is Verra.

Verra markets itself not as a seller of carbon offsets, but as a company that provides reliable carbon standards.

What sets Verra and its competitors apart is their efforts to provide internal offset verification services.

In Verras case, that means recruiting, training, and maintaining a network of auditors who can follow up on any Verra-approved offset programs. Its in-house offset project verification, trying to ensure that a ton of carbon offset is an actual ton of carbon gone. Thats easier said than done, and it requires an extensive network.

But with a market growing as rapidly as the carbon offset market, the potential prize is worth it.

What Verra and others are pushing for is the chance to be the de facto verification body for an entire industry.

That push may seem to run against the market, but consumers will have the last word as always. The difference between carbon offset projects may not be apparent immediately, but as the market grows it will be easier to choose offsets based on reputation.

A standard for carbon offsets doesnt need to be government-issued.

The markets can and will set their own standards.

I, for one, applaud that.

To follow real-time updates on carbon prices for free you can click here.

Until tomorrow.

All the best,

Sean

From Russia With Mowie Wowie

Posted August 05, 2022

By Sean Ring

Happy Friday! Grab that most excellent cup of joe and a seat. I’m going to do something I’ve never done while writing the Rude. I will attempt to write about something I don’t...

Here Comes the Reign Again

Posted August 04, 2022

By Sean Ring

I’m getting used to NYC coffee in the mornings again.  Though I must admit, I miss the blue Greek coffee cups that seem to have disappeared. Credit: My Recipes What I’m not...

Taiwan or Not Taiwan, That is the Question

Posted August 02, 2022

By Sean Ring

House Speaker Pelosi insists on visiting Taiwan. China insists she will do as she’s told. Will the 82-year-old replace Helen of Troy for future generations?

Monthly Asset Class Report

Posted July 29, 2022

By Sean Ring

Everything is up this month. Stocks, bonds, commodities, the dollar, and crypto all rallied. But is it a trend change or just another sucker’s rally?

Do Hikes Produce a “Sentiment Recession?”

Posted July 28, 2022

By Sean Ring

The Fed hiked 75 bps again. The markets rallied big yesterday. But technically, we’re still in No Man’s Land. Happy Thursday! My goodness, I need to stop partying in the Big Apple. Besides dealing with...

What is the Cantillon Effect?

Posted July 27, 2022

By Sean Ring

Happy Hump Day! Last night, I drank a few drops of something cheerful with my new Irish friend Simon, who’s training the same bankers I am. He reminded me that I haven’t...